Sunday, November 22, 2026

Jury rules in favor of judge in libel suit; awards $105,000

BRUNSWICK COUNTY — A Brunswick County jury on Friday evening ruled in favor of Senior Resident Superior Court Judge Ola Lewis in her libel lawsuit against Ed Rapp, a Boiling Spring Lakes political activist.

Lewis sued Rapp for libel for an April 2010 blog posting in which Rapp questioned her judicial ethics for campaigning for then-candidate State Sen. Bill Rabon.

The jury found Rapp did “know the statement was false or acted with reckless disregard,” when he posted the blog.

The jury ordered Rapp to pay $5,000 in actual damages and $100,000 in punitive damages.

“It is a sad day for political activism in Brunswick County,” Rapp said following the decision.

Lewis declined to comment.

It was a tale of two judges during Friday’s closing arguments.

The first was described as an innovative, compassionate, hardworking judge whose legal reputation is beyond reproach.

The second—a driven, ambitious, disloyal politician who would do anything to advance her career or the career of those who she chooses—one not to mess with.

Friday marked the conclusion of testimony in the libel suit in which Lewis sued Rapp for libel for a 2010 blog posting in which he questioned her support and of Rabon and if it were proper judicial conduct.

Hugh Stevens, Rapp’s Raleigh-based media law and First Amendment attorney, said in his closing arguments this case boiled down to one thing—politics.

“She’s the senior resident superior court judge. That’s not enough. She told you to your faces, ‘I want to be on the Supreme Court. I want to run for the highest court in the state.’

“Do you suppose it’s possible—is it possible the reason is that it’s a way of sending a message to anybody who might stand in her way? Is it possible that what it’s really about is what Mr. [Mike] Forte said, ‘Don’t mess with that lady,’” Stevens said.

Lonnie Williams Sr., Lewis’ attorney, asked the jury to award Lewis “a substantial amount of money to compensate her for her loss of reputation.”

“Any amount of punitive damages is an excessive amount,” Stevens said.

“He’s already suffered enough—to have a superior court judge dragging you through the courts. What more does she want? Does she want him to declare bankruptcy? Does she want him to move out of Brunswick County?

“It’s pretty clear she wants him to shut up and it’s pretty clear she wants a lot of people to shut up. She wants that message sent, ‘Don’t mess with us,’” Stevens said.

Stevens told jurors the blog posting and the blog site were “puny.”

“There are a billion and a half people in China who know nothing about this. It’s all about politics in a little corner of North Carolina, in one party in that corner. What it’s really about is one thing—it’s an attempt to intimidate people into not crossing Judge Lewis.

“It’s about what Mr. Forte said, ‘Don’t mess with her,’” Stevens said.

Williams said the matter was nothing more than media sensationalism—newspaper reporters’ compulsive need to “stir up controversy” to sell newspapers.

Williams accused three reporters covering the case of sitting in Rapp’s “corner” so the media could print anything about anyone with no repercussions and “there’s nothing you can do about it.”

Williams said Rapp had a “bevy of news media people who would back up the devil himself if it aided their purpose.

“If somebody accuses you of some crime of moral turpitude, then you have a cause for that. [The media] would like to strip that of you just like they would want to strip Judge Lewis of her right,” Williams said.

“Our Supreme Court has talked about how important a good name is. A good name is a man’s most precious possession,” Williams said.

Stevens also addressed Lewis’ name.

“My name is my brand. It’s like Coca-Cola,” Lewis said Thursday.

“What is it that would cause someone to say, ‘Mr. Stevens, my name is my brand. My brand’ ? How many of you think about your name as your brand? I have my name on my business, my law firm. I don’t even think of my name as my brand. A brand is for a product or service, like Orkin or Coca-Cola,” Stevens said.

Williams disagreed with Stevens’ assertion very few people read the blog postings at all, saying “perhaps hundreds of thousands of people read it.”

Williams said Lewis sought the lawsuit because it was her only remedy.

“It’s not about politics,” Williams said, adding it was so other people “had good reason not to make allegations about judicial conduct or judicial ethics or other people who are said to have breached statutes involving moral turpitude,” Williams said.

Click here to read previous trial coverage.

 

Related Articles