Thursday, November 19, 2026

Southport Crossing denied additional residential units for second time

A residential development that has been before Southport leadership boards multiple times in the last two decades returned earlier this month to the aldermen with a request to double its density. (Courtesy Southport)

SOUTHPORT — A residential development that has been before Southport leadership boards multiple times in the last two decades returned earlier this month to the aldermen with a request to double its density.

Charlotte-based developers Edgehill REC, LLC want to add 50 units to Hillstead at Southport Crossing; its previously approved plan from 2019 allows 60 units. The developers were denied a request to increase to 130 units last May. 

Aldermen came down in a 3-3 split vote to deny the project on Nov. 12, with Marc Spencer, Rebecca Kelley and Karen Mosteller in favor. Mayor Joe Pat Hatem broke the tie.

READ MORE: Denied Southport Crossing plans return with modifications

ALSO: Traffic, flooding concerns thwart Southport Crossing residential expansion

“If anyone comes before the board and can’t convince four of you that this project is good for Southport, then it should not go forward,” the mayor said. 

The board was torn after hearing roughly a dozen or so people speak during the public hearing. The majority of residents opposed Hillstead, citing strained infrastructure, from traffic to flooding to emergency service impacts. 

Bonnie Carver, who has lived in the area for 52 years and whose home is near the proposed development, said adding hundreds of vehicles to nearby roads daily could be an impediment to safety, whether evacuating or in case of an emergency. She talked about a brush fire near her home recently and worried about response times decreasing from emergency personnel if more traffic came to the area.

“[It] came within a few feet of our home,” Carver explained. “And every second counted. Had there been 200 or 300 cars on the road that day, I fear the fire department would not make it to our home in time.”

Hillstead is located near N.C. Highway 211 and N.C. Highway 133 corridors and is anticipated to bring 722 daily trips. 

A formal traffic impact study is required in Southport for PUDs when the estimated traffic generated exceeds 800 trips per day. The developers did an updated traffic count and found traffic will be 29% below what NCDOT anticipated when the development was first approved years ago. The TIA from 2008 included the overall master plan for Southport Crossing, including the commercial component — now home to Lowe’s Foods, Starbucks and other businesses. Then it was expected to bring 20,362 trips daily; today, that number is 14,558. Hillstead developers hired DRP Engineers to reassess since the widening of Highway 211 has been underway.

The project also has been promoted as walkable between the residential portion and commercial businesses, something developers said has proven popular with developments in Charlotte and Raleigh. However, many residents who spoke during Southport’s hearing said the lack of sidewalks on the outer perimeter of the shopping center and along main corridors defies the promotion.

“Just calling it walkable doesn’t make it one,” resident Francesca Slaughter said. “This is already a busy shopping center.”

Rivermist resident Shirley Sullivan claimed there were around 50 accidents in the Southport Crossing parking lot in the last few years, also pointing to its lack of crosswalks. 

Her husband, Rich, told aldermen when accounting for a lack of public right-of-ways on N.C. 133 and N.C. 211: “You’re sending people out into disaster.”

However, most of the complaints centered on stormwater. Alderman Paul Gross asked for more details surrounding water runoff.

Tim Clinkscales of Paramounte Engineering, Inc. — who has worked on the throughout its entire duration — clarified they have engineered the site to decrease stormwater flow by 50% from what’s currently allowed. 

The team increased stormwater facilities 88.3%, with four stormwater ponds, built to meet capacity four times than what’s been designed before. This will meet Southport’s requirement to for runoff to be captured for a 100-year-storm event. DMV also built culverts from where the runoff will go to meet the 100-year storm event as well, Clinkscales said.

Sue Lantman, who lives in Rivermist, questioned where the water would be diverted to exactly. 

“Is it being directed into a swale surrounding Rivermist?” she asked. 

Last month, developers said it would flow into wetlands and culverts under Long Beach Road, or N.C. 133, which leads to Dutchman Creek.

The Rivermist neighborhood is located at Dutchman Village, whose runoff also goes into the creek. The residents reminded the aldermen they recently pushed back against Pointe Grand development’s pushing runoff to their properties, without Rivermist’s permission, and feared the same would happen here. Brunswick County commissioners voted to reverse Pointe Grand’s stormwater permits in September; the project is in the unincorporated area of Brunswick County.

“We have to stop bending a knee to these developers,” Sullivan said. “Why should new developments be favored over existing residents? You already have our tax money; now, do your job by denying this expansion.”

Additionally, Clinkscales explained when the current 60 units were approved for the project in 2019, the ponds grandfathered in were to built to a 25-year storm event. So the project today will exceed capacity.

“I’m a blunt guy,” he said. “All this demagoguery everyone is getting about flooding may have truth. But to say this piece of property is going to flood the town of Southport is just not fair to this property owner and this development. We are handling greater stormwater than anyone else will handle in this area.”

Alderman Lowe Davis, who noted earlier she would not be voting for the project and applauded the audience for speaking “eloquently and persuasively” about their concerns, took offense to Clinkscales’ use of the word demagoguery: “Surely you didn’t mean to use it the way it was incorrectly used?”

“Ma’am I don’t know the correct way to do it, but I feel like there is a lot of hyperbole that’s being said here,” he said. “You said the public adequately stated their concerns, but a professional engineer should have some credibility that they’re telling the truth.”

The engineer noted, outside of storms beyond their control — like PTC8 — his firm hasn’t seen flooding issues overtopping N.C. 211 due to development. He further clarified the ponds were designed before to capture 10 inches of rain an hour, plus or minus in 24 hours. 

“Changing to a 100-year flood, now it’s 13.3 inches an hour by NOAA,” he said. 

A group of petitioners, featuring 260 signatures, had listed stormwater as a main issue, as well as density in general. That was Alderman Kelley’s concern, though the development comes under allowed density. Zoned a planned unit development, Hillsdale can have 288 units — or 6 dwelling units per acre. The 110 units equals 2.3 dwelling units per acre, almost double the approved 1.3 dwelling units per acre for 60 units. 

Kelley remained cautious about denying a project that could potentially bring more thoughtful infrastructure to the area. If Edgehill developers walked away and new developers came in, she said they would just stick with the old plan and outdated ordinance requirements.

“Is stormwater your only concern?” Alderman Robert Carroll asked her.

“Not only, but I want to understand it for these neighbors,” she said. “I don’t like the idea of additional density, but there is a trade-off here. And one of biggest concerns is stormwater and potentially more can flow off site with 60 versus 110 units, so that’s a big consideration. … I really like the idea of making sure the stormwater is very well controlled above and beyond the requirement. That serves the neighboring area.”

Tyler Covington, managing partner at Edgehill, told the board the group ran an impervious surface analysis on concrete, driveways, roads, and rooftops for 60 units and the 110 proposed and found they’re identical.

“Units are half the size from what they would be built under the current plan,” he said.

It was a change in tone from earlier in the meeting when he told Davis, for aldermen to disapprove of their plan would set “a dangerous precedent.” Covington emphasized the developers followed the city code and future land use plan.

“Even if you comply with zoning, even if you comply with the stormwater requirements, you’re saying you’re not welcome in Southport — we don’t want your business,” Covington said.

It was something Mayor Pro Tem Mosteller struggled with. She said the aldermen spent months, with input from the public, on what they wanted their land code to look like.

“And this development checks many boxes in the comprehensive plan,” she said. “Even with 110 units, the future land use allows 3-4 dwelling units for this property and they’re working out to 2.3. That’s why they came here asking for this because it’s in our planning document.” 

The residential portion of the development will consist of all townhomes, a change from the previously approved 32 residential-attached and 28 single-family lots, and include 24 buildings in total. There also will be 300 parking spaces and 31 acres of open space (three times the amount required under city code) — of which 8.52 acres are upland and 22.52 acres of wetlands, not to be disturbed.

The development will consist of rentals, as revealed by the developers at both the planning board and aldermen meetings in previous months. Edgefield developers said previously it was a product not offered yet in Southport but is growing from Florida, Georgia and the Carolinas.

This was agreed upon by Sandy and Dave Sherman, one of a few in the public hearing who favored Hillstead. The Shermans thought adding more units would bring housing costs down, especially needed during a time when prices “rise faster than wages.”

“Teachers, nurses, first responders and young families are finding it harder to live in the community they serve,” they wrote in for the clerk to read during the hearing. “When supply doesn’t keep up with demand, prices rise.”

Gross asked planning services director Mo Meehan how many rental units are within 10 miles of the vicinity of where the project is planned. She didn’t have an exact number, but when Gross further suggested more than 100 or 200, she said she could think of one development that has at least 500 units.

Meehan reminded the aldermen the board can’t legally base its decision on whether a project will be a rental or include home ownership: “We need to make sure to take that off the table. There is case law that says you can’t make that kind of decision.”

Developers told the aldermen last month the product would be a rental, something numerous speakers who stepped up to the podium during the hearing mentioned. They pointed to plenty of rentals already in the area — Evolve Apartments, Coastside Apartments, Southport Meadows and Pointe Grand — some with vacancies still.

“We’re being asked to put the toothpaste back in the tube because once the developer talked about these going to be rentals, we can’t forget it,” Davis said. “But more so, every time we say yes, it makes it harder to say no later.”

Davis, who stood fast on representing the people who elected the aldermen, read the motion to deny, which ultimately passed.


At Port City Daily, we aim to keep locals informed on top-of-mind news facing the tri-county region. To support our work and help us reach more people in 2026, please, consider helping one of two ways: Subscribe here or make a one-time contribution here.

We appreciate your ongoing support.

Shea Carver
Shea Carver
Shea Carver is the editor in chief at Port City Daily. A UNCW alumna, Shea worked in the print media business in Wilmington for 22 years before joining the PCD team in October 2020. She specializes in arts coverage — music, film, literature, theatre — the dining scene, and can often be tapped on where to go, what to do and who to see in Wilmington. When she isn’t hanging with her pup, Shadow Wolf, tending the garden or spinning vinyl, she’s attending concerts and live theater.

Related Articles