The lawsuit against Empowered Investor, the investment firm formed by state Sen. Thom Goolsby and James Upham, has been dismissed.
But the suit’s 10 plaintiffs are still seeking damages through arbitration.
The lawsuit was filed in New Hanover County Superior Court on July 10 and transferred in August to N.C. Business Court after it was deemed “mandatory complex business,” dealing in securities law, according to court records.
The matter was voluntarily dismissed by the plaintiffs on Sept. 12.
On Sept. 16, the American Arbitration Association initiated arbitration between the parties, according Mitchell Baker of Baker and Slaughter, the firm representing the plaintiffs.
Expected to take nine months to a year, arbitration is ideal in a case like this, Baker explained, because it can be a quicker process than litigation, which can take years.
“You pick three judges who generally are experienced in the area, instead of a jury of 12 people. It is preferable in complicated cases such as securities cases,” Baker said.
Once a judgment is issued, it’s final and there’s no appeals process.
“The arbitration is like a judgment you have in court. It’s been confirmed. Either we make a recovery or we don’t,” he said.
The lawsuit claimed Goolsby and Upham told clients they would adhere to a “10-20-50” investing rule, “whereby it always sold an investment if its value decreased by 10 percent, it looked for any and every reason to sell an investment if its value increased by 20 percent and it never invested more than 50 percent of an account in the market at one time.”
But the suit stated they instead invested in “highly volatile and speculative investments,” which were not suitable for the clients. Losses cited by clients in the lawsuit ranged from 20 percent to 95 percent.
An attorney for Empowered Investor previously said the claims were without merit.
“All Empowered Investor’s clients sign risk disclosure agreements and understand the volatility of the stock market,” Melissa Gott said. “Empowered Investor’s clients specifically consent and agree to any market risks.”
“You can’t contract away liability,” Mitchell responded, “That’s not the law in North Carolina.”
Related stories:
Lawsuit against Sen. Goolsby’s investment firm dismissed
Clients sue Sen. Goolsby’s investment firm
Caroline Curran is the managing editor at Port City Daily. Reach her at (910) 772-6336 or [email protected]. On Twitter: @CGCurran

