A newly released appraisal report commissioned by the owner of the Hilton Wilmington Riverside contends the dirt value of a site the city plans to sell to the developer of an Embassy Suites is worth several times the going price set by the city.
Sotherly Hotels included the appraisal, by the Florida-based Keystone Consulting Group, in a final letter to the city Wednesday asking Wilmington City Council to take a step back in the sale proposal and consider a new deal that wouldn’t, as alleged, subsidize the Embassy Suites.
“The City should not be in the business of picking winners and losers by subsidizing one private developer’s project to the disadvantage of others,” Matthew Davis, a Wilmington attorney representing Hilton owner Sotherly, wrote to the mayor and council.

It comes ahead of a vote scheduled for Tuesday on the sale, and its approval would be a major milestone in the years-long effort to secure a new hotel that would serve as the accommodations companion to the city’s Wilmington Convention Center.
Related story: Terms of convention center hotel land sale heads to council
The 186-room Embassy Suites proposed by developer Harmony Hospitality would, according to the city, help with the city-built convention center’s marketing and boost accommodations-tax revenues that support the facility.
But the city’s sale price of less than $579,000 for the riverside land slated for the Embassy Suites is unjustly low, Sotherly alleges. The company commissioned an appraisal of the land, from Keystone, that determined $2.8 million was the fair value.
Keystone said it came up with its figure after a site visit in February and an analysis of market data. The report did not include a review of environmental or other survey reports.
Further, Sotherly attorney Davis wrote Wednesday, council needs to consider the value of parking for the private hotel. A separate city agreement proposed would reserve 250 spaces in the convention center deck at $100 per month per space, which the city noted is the publicly established parking rate.
The appraisal report Davis attached put a value of $15,000 per space per room at the proposed Embassy Suites, figured on development costs.
“Taken together, then, the fair market values of the proposed agreements exceed $5 million,” Davis wrote, adding that regardless of whether the city agrees with that valuation precisely, there’s “clearly a material disconnect” between it and the city’s selling price.
It was the fourth letter since mid-August from Davis to the city disputing the current valuation. Past letters requested details on its origin.
Past story: City turns down Hilton’s proposal for new appraisal of convention center hotel land
The city has maintained all along that it reached its valuation fairly and in line with a 2006 consent judgment that forbids the city from subsidizing a private hotel for the convention center. (Related story)
“Finalizing these agreements is a significant milestone in our progress toward the private building of a high quality hotel for our convention center,” City Manager Sterling Cheatham said in a release from the city last week. “We are working hard to finalize a deal that is in the city’s best interest while partnering with a first-class hotel developer.”
Harmony, based in Virginia Beach, Va., has a portfolio of 12 hotels or inns of various brands in the Old Dominion and Tar Heel states, according to its website. Officials involved with the estimated $33.6 million Wilmington Embassy Suites project have noted investment interest from persons in foreign countries like China, but the company has been waiting on approval from the federal government.
Despite the long wait on that end, Brooks Johnson, development director for Harmony, has assured city officials the project’s financing is coming down the pike.
“You will have an Embassy Suites hotel in Wilmington very soon,” he told the city council in May.
The foreign fundraising is hoped for through the federal EB-5 program, also known as the Immigrant Investor Program. Administered by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, the program affords visas to foreign investors for the purposes of domestic economic development, but it has a waiting period for approvals that has extended beyond Harmony’s expectations.
Davis, the attorney for Sotherly, noted the financing in his letter Wednesday. He called it an uncertainty that should cue the city to hold off on the land sale.
“The ultimate question to be asked against this backdrop of delay and uncertainty is: Why would the City go under contract with Harmony at all right now?” Davis wrote.
Said the city last week, “The agreements are among the last items that must be approved by the City Council and worked out before Harmony can begin construction, which is expected to begin in early 2014.”
The public will have the chance to speak on the land sale and parking agreements at Tuesday’s city council meeting, 6:30 p.m. in the chambers at Wilmington City Hall, 102 N. Third St.
Ben Brown is a news reporter at Port City Daily. Reach him at [email protected] or (910) 772-6335. On Twitter: @benbrownmedia

