A judge has denied New Hanover County Commissioner Brian Berger’s request for reimbursement of attorneys’ fees and costs resulting from his appeal of his removal from the board of commissioners in May.
Special Superior Court Judge James Gale, whose ruling in that appeal reinstated Berger to the board earlier this month, filed an order today denying Berger’s motion for attorneys’ fees and costs, while also denying the county’s counter motion that sought sanctions against Berger’s attorney, Christopher Anglin, of Raleigh. (Related story)

Anglin filed a motion asking the court to have the county pay Berger’s attorneys’ fees, citing a statute that he said required the reimbursement if the board’s action was deemed “an abuse of discretion” or if commissioners “acted outside the scope of their authority” in removing Berger in May through a procedure called amotion.
Gale, who upheld the board’s use of amotion but deemed the removal tainted by comments from commissioners, ruled in his order Wednesday that the county did not act outside the scope of its authority within the meaning of that statute, and that the county did not abuse its discretion.
“Therefore, the award of attorneys’ fees is discretionary and not mandatory,” Gale says in his order, “and the court should and does hereby exercise its discretion and refuses the request attorneys’ fees or costs to be taxed against the county…”
The order goes on to say Berger and the county “shall each bear their respective costs and fees”—the amount of which has yet to be made public.
Anglin has recently noted Berger is accepting donations to cover his legal expenses, while the county has said it won’t know the cost of defending itself against Berger’s appeal until it receives a final invoice from John Martin, the Greensville-based attorney the county hired for the case.
Related story: Berger attorney soliciting donations for client’s legal fees; county yet to be billed
County officials have said the full cost of the amotion process could not be known until that bill is received.
Commissioners opted last week to refrain from pursuing a second amotion hearing, instead adopting a list of rules that Berger must abide by to remain on the board. Berger’s term in office expires in late 2014.
Related stories:
- Judge restores Berger to New Hanover County Board of Commissioners
- Attorneys claim accomplishments in Berger removal reversal; county ‘weighing options’
- Berger allowed to remain on board; commissioners will not pursue removal, for now
Jonathan Spiers is a reporter for Port City Daily. He can be reached at (910) 772-6313 or [email protected]. On Twitter: @jrspiers

