BOLIVIA—Senior Resident Superior Court Judge Ola Lewis says her name is her brand, like Coca-Cola.
During a three-hour cross examination Thursday in the second day of testimony in her libel suit against Ed Rapp, a political activist from Boiling Spring Lakes, Lewis said, “My name is my brand. It’s like Coca-Cola. As a sitting judge, it means something to anyone who hears it.”
But, under court order, a fellow judge testified Lewis’ reputation was not what she claimed.
“As far as her reputation for political activity, Judge Lewis has a reputation for being an energetic, single-minded, driven politician who advances those politicians who she wishes to be successful,” District Judge Marion Warren said.
“Judge Lewis went to the district court bench in 1992. She has always been in the exact sense of the word ‘ambitious,’” Warren said.
Warren said he only recently learned Lewis planned to subpoena him in the trial. He was released from Lewis’ subpoena, but Special Superior Court Judge Frank Williamson ordered Warren to testify in the matter as a defense witness.
“She said that she did not know for what purpose…there was some additional information I might be able to shed light on. I told her I believed it was a mistake for me to be called and, for the both of us, for me to be here today. I think it reflects poorly on the judiciary,” Warren said.
Thursday marked the second day of testimony in the libel lawsuit in Brunswick County Superior Court.
Lewis sued Rapp for libel for a blog posting written in April 2010 about Lewis’ judicial conduct. After several rounds in court, including a trip to the North Carolina Court of Appeals, the matter has come back before Brunswick County jurors.
Lewis and her attorney Lonnie Williams Sr. contend Rapp published a Facebook posting, followed by a blog posting about her campaigning for then-candidate State Sen. Bill Rabon, who Lewis described Wednesday as her Godfather and a man she’s known since she was 16 years old.
Lewis admitted to openly supporting Rabon in 2010, which she said was permissible as a judicial candidate.
Williams said Rapp wrote on Facebook, “When sitting judges violate the canons of ethics by campaigning for a candidate in violation of those standards, we’re in dirty politics.”
Williams claimed Rapp followed with a blog posting in which he accused Lewis of being in violation of North Carolina Judicial Standards by campaigning for Rabon despite Williams’ contention he alerted Rapp to an amendment following a U.S. Supreme Court opinion that judges who are candidates are allowed to campaign.
When she was first alerted to the Facebook posting, Lewis called GOP Chairman George Bell, then-7th District GOP Chairman Frank Williams and John Pannullo, another GOP representative, to ask Rapp to remove the Facebook posting. Soon after, Lewis engaged Lonnie Williams as counsel in the matter.
Hugh Stevens, a Raleigh-based attorney representing Rapp, asked Lewis what it was she wanted from this lawsuit.
“Sir, I want this jury to determine what my reputation is worth,” Lewis said.
“In other words, you want money,” Stevens countered, to which she replied, “No, sir. That is not correct. I want this jury to determine what my 22 years of hard work and dedication to this community is worth.”
But the jury in this matter can’t give Lewis “any remedy in this case except money,” Stevens said. “You’re not here contending you have sustained any kind of financial damage?” Stevens questioned.
“I continue to draw my salary,” Lewis responded.
As a senior resident superior court judge, Lewis makes about $129,000 annually, plus the state healthcare package and state-funded retirement. Lewis is eligible for retirement with full benefits in four years, Stevens said.
Stevens asked Lewis if she was aware Rapp has publicly apologized and retracted his comments made in the blog posting.
“You nor Mr. Rapp [have] never contacted me to personally to apologize,” Lewis said.
District Judge Pauline Hankins, described by Lewis as her “dear friend and sister in cross,” spoke to Lewis’ reputation on the bench and in the community.
Hankins said Lewis has a reputation of being fair, appropriately administering the law and keeping an orderly courtroom.
“As an African-American judge in the Republican Party,” Hankins said the lawsuit would prevent further false claims being made against her, Lewis or other minority judges.
Hankins’ reference to minority judges was the second mention of race during Thursday’s testimony–the first was a comment Lewis made about a N.C. Bar Association judicial evaluation.
Though Williamson previously disallowed email correspondence between Lonnie Williams and attorneys in which Lonnie Williams solicited favorable responses of Lewis to the Bar Association survey, Stevens asked about comments Lewis received in the survey.
“Plays favorites with certain attorneys,” Stevens said. “Routinely dismisses cases based on the identity of the attorney involved,” Williams wrote about the negatives comments of Lewis.
“Rules in favor of the party based on who is representing them. Can’t discuss partiality without suffering the same result at a later date. Does not issue orders in a timely manner. Appears to favor attorneys and parties from her district,” Stevens said.
Lewis said the bar survey was improperly conducted and the results of which weren’t posted, adding she had six favorable reviews.
“The performance evaluations of minority judges have been lower than evaluations than non-minority judges, including Pauline Hankins, A. Jones…They are not a true and accurate measure of a judge’s capability,” Lewis said.
Lewis openly campaigned for Hankins during her 2012 election to the district bench. Lewis said she was permitted to campaign for Hankins because in April she wrote a letter to Judicial Standards indicating she was seeking a seat on the North Carolina Supreme Court in 2014.
Several other defense attorneys, law enforcement officers and community members testified on behalf of Lewis and her reputation Thursday.
Testimony continues Friday. Be sure to check portcitydaily.com for trial updates.
Reach Caroline Curran at (910) 772-6336 or [email protected]. On Twitter at @cgcurran.

