Monday, November 16, 2026

Here’s who threw their hats in the ring to manage the Oak Island pier complex

Could Oak Island's fixed up restaurant pier complex see a new Trolly Stop or Swain Seafood Shack?

Six applicants are vying to operate various aspects of Oak Island's renovated pier complex. (Port City Daily photo/ Courtesy Google Maps)
Six applicants are vying to operate various aspects of Oak Island’s renovated pier complex. (Port City Daily photo/ Courtesy Google Maps)

OAK ISLAND — The town is looking for someone to run its renovated pier complex and several area restaurant owners are vying for the spot.

Six entrepreneurs applied for the job. Oak Island is looking to lease out its entire pier house complex, including a 1,400 sq. ft. restaurant, pier, tackle shop, retail space and new event venue across the street.

Related: Oak Island is looking for parking revenue, someone to run its pier complex

Five applicants are bidding to run the restaurant, formerly The Flying Fish Cafe. And two hope to run the pier, tackle shop and retail space.

Who’s in the running?

Trolly Stop Grill & Catering, under the applicant Samuel Roberts, pitched in to run the restaurant for four years, paying $3,000 a month the first year. The hot dog spot, with its first location out of Wrightsville Beach, has expanded in recent years to Chapel Hill.

The town’s previous pier operator, Tommy Thomes, is asking to operate the pier, tackle shop, and retail space for $2,000 in rent per month for the first year. Thomes is the only applicant not seeking to run the restaurant. In 2017, Thomes sued the town, claiming Oak Island failed to communicate and make repairs to the pier for months after a 150-foot section at the end of the pier was washed out by Hurricane Matthew. During that time period, Thomes sold season passes and purchased inventory for the bait shop, according to the State Port Pilot.

Austin Alfonso, the co-owner of Kai-Joe’s, an Oak Island-based Mexican breakfast and lunch spot, also applied to run the restaurant. Alfonso hopes to run “Ruby’s by The Sea” at a rent of $3,000 a month, including renting the town’s retail space.

Towhee Swain, of the family-run Swain Seafood Shack on Oak Island, could open up a second location at the pier. Swain applied to operate the new restaurant at $3,000 a month for five years.

Alan Boisvert applied to open “Pesky Pelican,” which would rent the restaurant, the pier, the tackle shop, and retail space. Boisvert operated Keon’s 105 Bistro in Haverhill, Massachusettes for 12 years before selling it to his head chef in 2017 and moving to North Carolina. For four years, Boisvert applied to rent all four spaces for $6,200 a month.

Lastly, James Moses hopes to run a restaurant called “Bleu Nautilus.” He co-owned The Trolley Stop, an ice cream shop in Morganton, North Carolina. He would rent the restaurant for $3,000 for four years.

Now what?

After the first year, rent rates would increase incrementally. Oak Island’s Town Council will review the six proposals Tuesday. The town’s staff is looking for direction from Council, according to an agenda item memo on the topic, so the facilities can be open for “this season.”

Last month, the town’s public works department continued work on the pier complex. Rotten wood was removed and new wood was purchased for the deck, a staff report states. Work on the tackle shop, restaurant and event space at 801 Ocean Drive, continued.

Oak Island’s meeting is planned for 6 p.m. Tuesday and Oak Island Town Hall.


Send tips and comments to Johanna Ferebee at [email protected]

Related Articles