Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Southport shooter faces death penalty as judge rules in DA’s favor

The man charged with killing three people and injuring numerous others in Southport in September 2025 could face capital trial, after a judge found the death penalty was appropriate. The defense has argued for nine months to get rid of the designation, due to the mental capacity of Nigel Edge. (Port City Daily/File)

BRUNSWICK COUNTY — The man charged with killing three people and injuring numerous others in Southport in September 2025 could face capital trial, after a judge found the death penalty was appropriate. The defense has argued for nine months to get rid of the designation, due to the mental capacity of Nigel Edge. 

Edge, 40, was arrested last year for opening fire on the American Fish Company, leaving three dead and six injured. He faces numerous charges for the shooting, including three counts of first-degree murder, five counts of attempted first-degree murder, five counts of assault with a deadly weapon with intent to kill inflicting serious injury and one count of discharging a firearm into occupied property. 

He is represented by capital defender Matthew Geoffrion, who filed a motion to reschedule the Rule 24 hearing, citing Edge was not yet in a place to proceed to trial and may never be. The hearing, a requisite when seeking the death penalty, has been delayed roughly eight months, due to the defense asking for a test of Edge’s mental competency in February and for a continuance as he sought treatment in April. 

READ MORE: Judge rules Southport shooting suspect incompetent, orders psychiatric treatment

ALSO: Southport shooter to undergo further psychiatric evaluation, death penalty hearing moved

CATCH UP: Grand jury indicts Southport shooter on 18 counts

Judge Jason Disbrow determined Tuesday a capital designation was reasonable after Edge sought psychiatric treatment and evaluation. The result of his treatment was not made known at the hearing, and the district attorney’s office chose not to comment when Port City Daily asked. Though, the office did receive results of his capacity.

Earlier this year, Edge was first ordered for psychiatric evaluation by the court with medical experts determining he was incompetent, though both thought Edge had a chance for recovery through treatment. He was then transferred to state-owned Cherry Hospital in Goldsboro in April for treatment, including medication and therapy, where he has effectively been for the past six months.

While Edge’s competency for the trial is still in question, David said the designation is not final and could be reclassified by the court at a later time.

“And getting back to this capacity issue, your honor, if he never is restored to capacity, the death penalty would not be lawful and it would be removed from consideration,” District Attorney Jon David said.

However, the designation was found to be appropriate now. Judge Disbrow agreed with the prosecution’s reasoning regarding the severity and circumstances of the crime, and due to the fact that Edge’s mental capacity, or sanity, at the time of the crime cannot be determined. 

“I think we’ve got a current ethical issue, a future ethical issue, and we have a moral issue,” Geoffrion told Judge Disbrow Wednesday afternoon. “Why are we going to seek death on a man who is incapable — medically, psychiatrically, psychologically — incapable to proceed, and is very unlikely? What’s the point?”

As previously reported by Port City Daily, Edge has a recorded history of “delusional” beliefs and ideas. He has claimed the Oak Island Police Department, the Brunswick Medical Center and Generations Church are all part of a LGBTQ+, pedophilic cult and were conspiring against him. He also believed “American Idol” star Kellie Pickler attempted to poison his whiskey when he escorted her to the CMT Awards a decade ago. 

Edge’s behavior has been largely attributed by Geoffrion to PTSD and a traumatic head injury he sustained while in the Marines, detailed in Edge’s memoir, “Headshot: Betrayal of a Nation.” While serving in Iraq, Egde claimed he was shot, with bullet shrapnel stuck in his skull. He also claimed his injury was an international conspiracy targeting him and covered up by the military. 

“We understand that he is a Marine that was horribly injured during his time in Iraq. He got a traumatic brain injury and he struggled with serious mental illness for years,” David said at the hearing. “But those facts have to be balanced against the circumstances of the crime itself.”

Edge appeared at Tuesday’s hearing emotionless, dressed in a black shirt and khakis, with a noticeable limp. 

Geoffrion suggested, in addition to his client being incapable of proceeding to trial, the transition to a new district attorney would complicate the case. 

David announced his resignation last year and DA-elect JK Somers won the primary election against Assistant District Attorney Jenna Earley, who is also serving with David on the case. Somers is the presumptive winner, since there is not a Democratic challenger for district attorney in Brunswick County. He joined the DA’s office on Oct. 5 and is undergoing the onboarding process before he takes office in the new year. 

David explained Somers had previously interacted with Edge. Somers owns a civil and criminal practice law firm in the county, of whom David said Edge consulted at one point for “legal issues that were important to him at that time.” According to David, Somers handed him some referrals for veteran resources and hadn’t spoken to the defendant since, but was paid for the consultation. 

However, David further pointed out upon his exit this December, the state bar has recommended one of the assistant district attorneys take over the case.

“It should be well understood that the district attorney doesn’t personally handle the lion’s share of the cases in their office,” David said. “Instead, we have a team of almost 40 dedicated public servants who every day work on cases in team-like fashion.”

David also suggested the capital designation could be beneficial to Edge, by providing him extra protection, such as a second attorney for his case. Rules for a capital trial include being assigned specialized counsel, publicly funded experts and investigators, the right to two trials (one to determine guilt and the other to convince the court against execution) and an automatic appeal.

Geoffrion combatted the notion: “As to the state’s comment that this is somehow a gift to Mr. Edge in which he’s receiving more benefit by more counsel and more due process, I would send that gift back.”

Judge Disbrow ultimately found “the state has enumerated sufficient aggravating factors to exist to proceed in this matter as a capital offense.” 

Under North Carolina General Statute 15A-2000, a defendant who knowingly creates a great risk of death to more than one person by means of a weapon normally hazardous to the lives of more than one person, that defendant is death penalty eligible.

However, there has been a moratorium on executions statewide since 2006. The last person to be executed was Samuel Russell Flippen, by lethal injection for the murder of his 2-year-old step-daughter in 2006. 

Southport Police Chief Todd Coring, whose team responded to the September 2025 shooting, was in attendance Tuesday. 

“I’m glad to see we’re moving forward,” he told Port City Daily. 

After press, Coring also provided the following remarks in a press release: “As a community, we continue to remember Joy, Solomon, and Michael, their families and loved ones, the survivors, and everyone whose lives were forever changed that night. We respect the judicial process and the decisions being made by the District Attorney’s Office and the courts. As we move forward, let us continue to stand together — with compassion, strength, and support for one another.”

There is an administrative hearing for Edge’s case scheduled for Dec. 7.


Have tips or suggestions for Emily Sawaked? Email [email protected]  

At Port City Daily, we aim to keep locals informed on top-of-mind news facing the tri-county region. To support our work and help us reach more people in 2026, please, consider helping one of two ways: Subscribe hereor make a one-time contribution here.

We appreciate your ongoing support.

Related Articles