
NEW HANOVER — For the fifth cycle in a row, Novant Health New Hanover Regional Medical Center has received a C grade. National nonprofit Leapfrog released its fall 2026 safety grade report and found NHRMC declined since its spring grades in nurse communication, doctor communication and colon surgery infection rates, while central-line bloodstream infections, C. diff infections and discharge information improved. However, hospital leaders explained not all data was accounted for in this cycle.
“We acknowledge the scores,” Novant NHRMC President Laurie Whalin said at a press conference with local media Tuesday. “We know what the score is. We accept the scores, but we do say that this one deserves a little more context.”
Whalin said the hospital’s overall score did not increase due to the CMS experiencing what she called a “technology issue.” Leapfrog is a nonprofit organization that evaluates hospital safety and quality every spring and fall, scoring almost 3,000 hospitals across the nation. Scoring data comes from two sources: the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services and hospital-reported surveys. Leapfrog policy says data must be released within seven days of its reporting period — which would have been Aug. 31 for the fall cycle. CMS missed Leapfrog’s deadline.
READ MORE: Hospital score remains at a ‘C,’ Novant leadership confident in improvements
ALSO: Picketers demand action from county commissioners over Novant hospital care
The delay in CMS reporting resulted in July 2022 through June 2024 information being used for the third consecutive reporting cycle — not showing improvements Novant leadership say internal reports are reflecting.
For example, Novant says fall injuries are down 50% but CMS data reflected in Leapfrog shows a score of 0.745, which shows no improvement as it is the same as the past two grading cycles. Thus, roughly one fall resulting in injury for every 1,340 patients discharged is above the national average of 0.339.
“We’re monitoring and evaluating our data on a continuous basis,” Chief Clinical Officer Heather Davis said. “We know what that data is most real time.”
How does Leapfrog work?
Hospitals are evaluated by Leapfrog based on five categories: infections, problems with surgery, safety problems, practices to prevent errors and doctors, nurses and hospital staff. Among the five areas, there are 22 overall categories measured in two halves: process/structural and patient outcomes, with each half counting 50% of the overall Leapfrog grade.
Data from hospital-reported surveys tends to be more up-to-date than CMS’s reports. CMS typically uses information 1.5 to 2 years prior to the Leapfrog reporting period. Additionally, Leapfrog processes the information for several months prior to publication, causing a delay between patient care and hospital performance, and what is reported.
However, CMS’s technology issue resulted in data for “never events” not being released for the most recent Leapfrog reporting period, usually reported once annually. “Never events” include falls and trauma, air embolisms and foreign objects left in patients after surgery. Patient safety indicator data was also not updated. It usually covers a two-year period and lags behind current hospital information — sometimes being up to two years old by the time it’s reported.
Typically, this data is factored into a Leapfrog grade as a part of its safety problems category and is historically the hospital’s weakest performance. For this Leapfrog reporting cycle, all of the hospitals included will have data from previous years, meaning NHRMC’s scores of 0.093 per 1,000 Medicare discharges for objects left in patient — around eight times the national average — 0.745 for falls and trauma and zero for air embolism reflects what it received in the spring.
Whalin said Novant had multiple calls with Leapfrog raising its concerns over not having up-to-date CMS data but were told it was Leapfrog’s policy to use whatever data is available if new data has not been released. Novant said they were told by CMS updated information would be released this quarter, however it would be after the Leapfrog grade release.
“We were concerned this was going to continue the narrative that there’s no progress being seen, and so they [Leapfrog] understood our concerns,” Whalin said. “We’re disappointed but we understand that they’re holding true to their policies.”
However, Whalin said Leapfrog provides a calculator for hospitals to put in their most recent data. She says when NHRMC put its most recent data in the calculator — including for “never events,” the organization received a B.
Leapfrog provides the calculator so hospitals can see how their overall score was made, it is not designed to be a score prediction tool.
“They [Leapfrog] don’t like us predicting scores,” Whalin said. “But it’s our belief that we would have shown that upgrade this time in the rating.”
The scores
New Hanover Regional Medical Center — acquired by Novant in 2021 — has received a C score since fall of 2024; previously, the facility scored Bs. While the hospital has high performance in error prevention practices, it continues to fall under national averages in several communication and infection categories.
The latest round of data shows several patient experience ratings have dropped and rates of infection scores have improved. No new data was released for surgical complications or patient safety indicators, due to the CMS delay.
Infection scores are based on a scale of 1.0; a score of 1.0 meaning the rates of infection were expected and anything over means infections are higher. Colon surgery site infection received 1.26 — a minor increase from spring 2026’s 1.24. NHRMC score is about 1.6 times higher than the national average of 0.786.
NHRMC urinary catheter infection increased from the spring 2026 reporting cycle — which covered July 2024 through June 2025 — while the national average decreased. The catheter infection rates hit 0.572 compared to a 0.449 national average.
MRSA infections remain similar to the spring score and close to the national average at 0.656.
Central-line bloodstream infection and C. diff both had substantial improvements: Central-line bloodstream infection decreased from 0.648 in the spring to 0.555 in the fall. The C. diff score dropped to 0.161 and is nearly half the national average of 0.322.
“Our hospital-acquired infections — that is where we’ve seen continuing improvement in our raw numbers of infection,” Davis said.
In practices to prevent errors, NHRMC received the maximum score in five categories: leadership structures and systems and staff working together to prevent errors are scored 0 to 120, the latter being the max score. Computerized medication ordering, barcode medication administration and hand hygiene are scored up to 100.
CMS data isn’t used for these scores, which are calculated through hospitals’ self-reported data submitted to Leapfrog via an annual survey.
Communication about medicines went up by one point to 73 out of 100 and communication about discharge escalated by a point to 85 out of 100.
Staff practices to prevent errors scores were above national averages. While total nursing care hours per patient each day and ICU physician staffing were given the maximum score of 100, doctor and nurse communication both fell under the national average. Nurse communication dropped two points since the spring, hitting 89. The national average is 90.67.
Doctor communication also scored an 89, going down from 90 in the spring. The national average is 90.02.
“MD communication was a little stagnant, but then our physicians, they’re very competitive, and took charge of that,” Whalin commended. “And, really, we started to see improvements, again, in this fourth quarter.”
What Novant is doing to improve
While Whalin noted the scores used for Leapfrog aren’t always based on the most up-to-date information, she added nothing in the fall report came as a surprise as the hospital has its own internal data collection. The hospital is aware of the information before it is released by Leapfrog.
“We already saw that data two years ago, and we’ve already been acting on it for the past two years,” Whalin said.
Throughout the media briefing, leadership cited real-time internal data tracking, regional quality tasks forces for Novant’s tri-county hospitals, relying on Vizient benchmarks — a private company which does not publicly release how it ranks participating hospitals —and patient and family advisory councils as steps being used to improve overall hospital performance and patient experience.
However, when Port City Daily queried what was in place to improve in areas where scores remained stagnant or declined, leadership did not give direct steps for moving forward.
“When we’re looking at the data over time, that’s where we’re seeing our trend down in a positive way,” Davis replied.
Whalin said the hospital has its sights on topping the grade scale for NHRMC.
“‘A’ and beyond is the end game,” she said. “We want to be the facilities that everyone’s looking at and saying: ‘Oh, how did they do that, and what are they doing to continue to maintain it?'”
Novant also oversees Brunswick Medical Center, which received an ‘A.’
Have tips or comments for Sophia DePhillips? Email [email protected]
At Port City Daily, we aim to keep locals informed on top-of-mind news facing the tri-county region. To support our work and help us reach more people in 2026, please, consider helping one of two ways: Subscribe here or make a one-time contribution here.

