A property owner’s request for a “good faith exception” to New Hanover County’s penalty for unauthorized clearing of trees failed to sway the board of commissioners, who said granting such an exception would hack away at the county’s tree protection ordinance.
At issue was the clearing of a five-acre lot along Chesterfield Drive in the Castle Hayne area. Owner L.P. Britton Jr. had that lot cleared without first obtaining a permit from the county, resulting in a penalty of $10,000 per acre and a three-year restriction on development of the property.
Matt Nichols, Britton’s attorney, said his client was unaware of the county’s tree ordinance and owned up to the error once informed by the county. In a hearing this week, Nichols said Britton asked for a “good faith exception”—via an amendment to the penalties under the current ordinance—in light of those circumstances, contending that $50,000 and a three-year restriction was excessive for what he described as an honest mistake.
Board Chairman Woody White said he agreed with some points Nichols made about inconsistencies between the ordinance and the state’s enabling legislation. He said the county’s current language does not allow it to take such circumstances into account or consider one violation more egregious than another.
While he recommended revisiting that language in the future, White and other commissioners maintained that the county’s current rules must be followed, and that granting an exception could discourage others from doing so.
“We need to follow the laws,” added Vice Chairwoman Beth Dawson, who said she did not support changing the rules for one property owner’s concerns.
“I just feel like it would send a terrible message to our development community and to our citizens to make a change, because so many are working hard and spending a lot of money to make sure the rules are followed,” she said.
Russ Britton, the owner’s son, stressed that the clearing would allow an existing business in the county to grow. He said the land would be used for a laydown yard for his business, Eco Express, which he described as dealing with protecting natural resources.
“I’m in the business of protecting trees,” he said, reiterating that he and his father “just didn’t know” the ordinance was in place. He added that the property is in an industrial zone, and said he and his father have complied with other permits.

Nichols added that the company his clients hired to remove the trees should have known about the ordinance and informed them about it. But Commissioner Jonathan Barfield took exception to that argument, especially considering that company was not represented at the meeting.
“You’re putting the onus on the tree company. In my opinion, it’s the owner’s responsibility to know what the rules are,” Barfield said.
Nichols reiterated that the three-year restriction on developing the property puts a hindrance on his clients. But county staff maintained that is the point of the ordinance: to impose penalties for violations, and to prevent others from occurring.
At White’s request, staff noted they recorded a total of 26 “significant” trees that were to be protected under the ordinance. Had the Brittons acquired a tree removal permit, mitigation costs for those trees’ removal would have totaled $123,000, staff said.
Russ Britton questioned whether those trees should have been classified as “significant,” contending differences in diameters between the base of trees and their trunks. He said trees in that area have considerable differences that should be taken into account when measuring stumps and determining whether those trees were protected.
“There is a very good chance there were no significant trees,” he said, prompting White to ask if he had evidence to present to argue that point. Britton replied that he and his father were expecting to have an opinion from an expert the following day.
“I just think it’s real excessive that we’re having to stop,” he told the board. “We have a great extension to our business; we’re going to bring a lot of jobs. We’ve got a lot of companies helping to launch the next wing of the company. So there’s no egregious movement here.”
Despite that, commissioners took no action on the request, encouraging staff instead to review the existing ordinance and recommend revisions as they see fit.
“I don’t want us to have paralysis here of doing the right thing just because of some technicality,” White said. “I have some concerns about the ordinance. As we’ve said, this ordinance and enforcing it does conflict with a very recognized need to create jobs and encourage development.
“I would not be opposed to changing it and making it better and letting them avail themselves of a better process with a more transparent-worded ordinance,” he said. “And if they got relief, great. But again, I did not hear any agreement from my other commissioners on that point, and so therefore I think it dies for a lack of any motion.”
Added Barfield: “My biggest concern is having someone hire an attorney to come in and say, ‘Oh I messed up; let’s change the rules.’ Imagine we had that happen in the criminal court system. We would never have anyone owning up for anything, and they could just pass the buck to someone else. And to put this off on a tree-cutting service that is not even here, I don’t know that any of that, for me, is credible.
“If you all were going to have an expert come in and speak, the meeting’s today,” Barfield said. “It’s not tomorrow. And you bring your A-game on the day that you’re playing the game, not the day after. So I can’t support the request the way that it’s laid out here.”
Jonathan Spiers is a reporter for Port City Daily. He can be reached at (910) 772-6313 or [email protected]. On Twitter: @jrspiers

